Skip to main content

ENGL 1920: Advanced Writing for Professionals: Scholarly vs. Popular

Scholarly Journals v. Popular Magazines

Scholarly Journals

  • Articles tend to be lengthy
  • Reading the articles requires your undivided attention
  • The author provides a complete list (bibliography) of the sources used
  • The entire issue is devoted to one topic, such as biology
  • Articles contain few pictures and advertisements
  • Often there are illustrations or graphs supporting the authors research
  • Articles usually are located by using a subject-oriented database such as PsycINFOHistorical AbstractsBiological Abstracts, etc.
  • The authors credentials are provided
  • The periodical is published or sponsored by a scholarly or a professional association or an academic press

Examples:  Psychological BulletinJournal of Physical ChemistryModern Fiction Studies  

Popular Magazines

  • Articles tend to be short
  • Articles are easy to read
  • There may be no indication of where the author got the information used in the article
  • The issue may be devoted to one or many topics
  • There often are many pictures
  • There are many advertisements
  • Articles are found using a general database such as Academic Search Complete
  • You may not know who wrote the article or the author's credentials
  • Periodical is published by commercial publisher

Examples:  Popular MechanicsNewsweekEbonySports Illustrated 

Scholarly vs. Popular Periodicals

Loyola Marymount University tutorial.

Peer Review in Three Minutes

Tutorial created by Anne Burke, Andreas Opphanides, Hyun-Duck Chung, Daria Dorafshar, Kyle Langdon, and Kim Duckett, NCSU Libraries.

Trade Publications

Trade Publications

  • Articles tend to be short, and are written for professionals in a particular field (engineering, business, etc.)
  • Articles often written by specialists, but are not generally peer-reviewed
  • Content often addresses new developments or technologies in the field
  • May contain advertisements
  • Periodical is published by a professional society or organization

Examples:   Professional Pilot, ISE., Special Warfare

Librarian

Lee Cummings's picture
Lee Cummings
Contact:
Pius Library, 202E
314-977-3590